Saga > Fréttir > Innihald

Galvanizing Vs Sherardizing

Sep 22, 2021

Sherardizing is also called thermal diffusion galvanizing (TDG), vapor galvanizing or  dry galvanizing, and it's is a specific process involving zinc powder and proprietary chemicals. Steel workpieces are cleaned before zinc coating process, and the cleaning process covers degrease and sandblasting, and then they are tumbled in a heated drum at temperatures slightly less than hot-dip galvanizing (680 - 825 degree F) so that matte gray HDG-like intermetallic alloy layers are produced.

Sherardized Rectangular Tubes (2).jpg
Galvanized Angles.jpg

While hot dip galvanizing (HDG)is a process of handling steel workpieces to go through a series of pretreatment, and then dipping  steel parts into the molten (830 F) zinc bath with, and workpiece is lowered into the kettle at an angle which allows air to escape from tubular shapes or other corners. During the dipping process, the iron metallurgically reacts with the zinc to form a series of zinc-iron intermetallic layers and an outer layer of pure zinc.



What's the difference between sherardizing and HDG?

The hot dip galvanizing process does not cause hydrogen embrittlement, but its pretreatment, acid pickling will cause embrittlement. HDG usually has rougher surface than sherardizing, and sherardizing is normally used for parts which requires strong anti-corrosion protection as well as tighter tolerance for assembly. Hot dip galvanized parts are widely used in infrastructure like motorway railing systems, cable racking system in tunnel and subway, solar energy, steel structure for bridge and construction. Sherardizing is widely used for fasteners and steel works which requires high precision assembly, and sherardizing production capacity is not as high as hot dip galvanizing because it's constrained by the tumbling drum.

Advantages of Sherardizing 

√  No risk of acid deposition around welded area

√  Complete elimination of hydrogen embrittlement

√  No need for re-threading or further fitting operations

√  Readily accepts top coats, no need for expensive primers

√  Withstand a fair measure of high industrial pollution and rough handling

√  Suitable for acting as a pre-coating for paints, powder coatings and rubber bonding

√  Hardest of all zinc coatings compared with hot dip galvanization, spin galvanization and zinc plating

√  Uniform coating, ideal for smaller and irregularly shaped items without unfavorable peak build up on 

    corners or on threads

√  Consists exclusively of intermetallic phase Fe-Zn, which permits the control of case depth and 

    ensures high corrosion resistance

√  Lower temperature process range, which avoids parts losing their mechanical properties and shapes 

    such as spring steels and fasteners

Due to the benefit of sherardizing, many steel products which require precision assembly as well as sound anti-corrosion protection are sherardized, such as fasteners,custom metal brackets, steel structure and steel sleepers.

Disadvantage of Hot Dip Galvanization

√  Galvanized water pipes can release lead into the water supply

√  Rough coating surface, and spikes tend to remain at the end of workpiece during lifting process 

    which needs to be removed during inspection

√  Due to the deposition of zinc, undercut nuts is required for fitting purpose, and the heat involved in 

    the galvanization process limits the grade of fastener

√  Due to its rough surface nature, it requires very strict control of sandblasting for uniform 

    galvanization surface.

In short, the biggest disadvantage of hot dip galvanization is its ununiformed surface which could cause assembly issues, specially for fasteners. Hot dip galvanization is a dominant metal surface treatment for infrastructure, telecommunication, agriculture, aquaculture, solar energy, mining and tunnel.

To visualize the fundamental facts about different zinc coatings, you can refer to the chart below for clearer understanding of cost, coating characters and relevant standards.

Cost

Sherardizing

Zinc   Plating 

Hot Dip   Galvanization

Mid Level

Low

Mid   Level

British EU Standards

BS   EN IS0 17668:201                        

BS7371 part 8:1999

BS1706/BS   EN 12329:2000
BS 3382 PART 2 for fasteners

BS   729/BS EN ISO 1461                                               

BS7371 part 6:1988 for fasteners 

Zinc Coating Thickness

15-80μm or more

5-25μm

30-200μm

Adhesion 

Excellent, alloy with substrate

Poor, no alloy with substrate

Good, some alloy with substrate

Uniformity

Excellent, vapour deposition ensures uniformity, ideal for iregularly shaped, recessed and threaded components and tight tolerance for precision assembly. 

Poor, molten zinc build up in drain points

Poor, zinc deposition on corners, threads and holes

Wear Resistance

Excellent, hardest of the zinc coating due to iron alloy. The coating can only be removed by chemicalor  mechanical solution.

Good, can withstand forming but mainly applied to finished components. 

Good, a tough durable coating but can't stand forming

Post Surface Treatment

Excellent, forms an excellent iron zinc alloy which accepts top coats without the need for primers or surface   preparation. Top coating like paints, powder coatings, Ecoating and rubber bonding is popular choice.

Poor, requires further processing to ensure adhesion

Poor, requires pretreatment like   sandblasting with extra attention to the blasting force, or suitable primer to ensure adhesion

Hydrogen Embrittlement

No risk, as no acid used and the process is dry and contains no sources of hydrogen.

High risk, due to acid use for pickling process. 

High risk, due to acid use for pickling process. 

Color  

Matte   grey

Popular   colors are yellow/gold, clear/blue, black and green.

Bright and shiny, but within a year, it will weather to a uniform dull gray appearance

Salt Spray Hours

Moderate coating thickness could reach 720 hours, and thicker coating could reach 1000   hours. 

With the addition of topcoats known as chromate, and the standard minimum is 96 hours.

For   moderate HDG thickness requirement, it shall pass 480   hours, and for high corrosive enviornment, thicker   coating is required for passing 720 hours.



Hringdu í okkur